2) The Wolf Among Us Season 2
Another Season 2 on this list, but this is one that’s sorely needed (and isn’t exactly guaranteed to happen). The Wolf Among Us served as an adaptation of the Fables series of books where fairy tale characters get placed in the R-rated real world. The first season brought players into an incredibly unique setting with fresh, original characters behind every corner. Along with that was a greatly intriguing mystery that stretched across all five episodes, remaining engaging all the way to the credits.
Telltale rarely confirms any additional seasons too far in advance (with Walking Dead being an exception), but with another outing of Game of Thrones confirmed, TWAU should be the next extended series. The IP receives very little representation outside of the Fables graphic novels and these games help preserve that great sense of variety in TT titles. That’s not even mentioning the cliffhanger ending that Season 1 ended on.
Out of Telltale’s already existing library, The Wolf Among Us is certainly the most deserving of a fresh set of episodes. They’ve got an excellent protagonist and a memorable cast of characters, all within a unique setting. That’s without even mentioning just how much of this game’s world remains unexplored. Come on TT, there’s got to be more mysteries in Fabletown for Sheriff Wolf to solve.